This policy is for Torbay Council:
- employees
- contractors
- partner agencies
- agency workers
- apprentices
- trainees
- volunteers
Complaints about Councillors
If you think a Councillor has not behaved as expected of the Members Code of Conduct, you can make a complaint about a Councillor.
Contents
- Introduction
- Scope
- Aims of the policy
- What is Whistleblowing?
- What is the difference between making a complaint and blowing the whistle?
- Safeguarding Whistleblowers
- Confidentiality
- Anonymous allegations
- Untrue allegations
- Procedure
- Advice and support
- Monitoring of the policy
- Equality statement
- Raising a concern outside of the Council
- History of Policy Chances
- Appendix 1. Process flow chart
- Appendix 2. FAQ's
Introduction
All of us at one time or another has concerns about what is happening at work. Usually these concerns are easily resolved. However, when they are about unlawful conduct, financial malpractice and similar wrongdoings, it can be difficult to know what to do.
Torbay Council is committed to creating an open and honest culture where people feel confident to speak up and raise concerns. We welcome concerns being raised and recognise that speaking up helps us improve services, protect the public and uphold our values.
The Whistleblowing Policy is to be used for reporting concerns where the whistleblower, the person who raises the concern, holds a reasonable belief that the concern is within the public interest or where the organisation, and/or members of it, may be at risk.
Scope
This policy applies to all employees of Torbay Council, contractors, partner agencies, agency workers, apprentices/trainees and volunteers who wish to raise concerns. Schools have their own local arrangements.
Separate arrangements exist for Elected Members which are covered within the ‘Code of Conduct for Members’ and ‘Local Protocol on Member and Officer Relations’ (available from Governance Support), provided they do not conflict with this Whistleblowing Policy or potentially prejudice a criminal or other investigation.
Complaints relating to Councillors can be addressed through theMembers Code of Conduct.
Individuals not engaged in work at the Council should use the corporate complaints procedure.
Aims of the policy
This policy aims to:
- Inform all within the scope of this policy how to appropriately take issues of concern forward, using the correct policies and procedures;
- Provide a clear procedure for all within the scope of this policy to speak up, raise concerns and receive feedback on any action taken;
- Ensure that confidentiality of the disclosure is maintained unless safeguarding concerns or criminal activity are disclosed;
- Reassure whistleblowers that they will be protected from reprisals or victimisation for ‘Whistleblowing’ or speaking up in good faith and in accordance with this procedure.
What is Whistleblowing?
Someone “blows the whistle” or raises a concern when they tell their employer, regulator, customers, the police or media about a dangerous or illegal activity they are aware of through work. The disclosure must be made in the public interest, i.e. the disclosure affects people beyond the individual worker. It’s about whether the concern has a wider impact on others - such as colleagues, service users, customers, the public, or the environment. It should be noted that in most cases if the person raising the concern, goes to the media they will lose their whistleblowing law rights as explained on Whistleblowing for employees: Who to tell and what to expect - GOV.UK
Whistleblowing legislation protects workers from dismissal, victimisation, or other detrimental treatment where they raise concerns about wrongdoing through appropriate channels.
The Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998 and the Employment Rights Act 1996 set out the circumstances in which a disclosure is protected under the law. These are known as protected disclosures and provide legal protection for workers who report certain types of wrongdoing in the public interest. The Employment Rights Act 2025 provides for sexual harassment to be added to the list of types of disclosure that qualify for protection under the whistleblowing provisions of the Employments Rights Act 1996.
A qualifying disclosure can be where any of the following is being, has been, or is likely to be, committed:
- a criminal offence for example fraud.
- a disclosure about sexual harassment in the workplace.
- a miscarriage of justice.
- an act creating risk to health and safety.
- an act causing damage to the environment.
- a breach of any other legal obligation; or
- a disclosure will also be protected if the information disclosed is of a nature that shows that any of the above is likely to be deliberately concealed.
The law also protects the individual from detrimental treatment by work colleagues for raising a concern. The Council is ‘vicariously’ liable for any wrongdoing of this nature unless it can prove that it took all reasonable steps to protect the individual who raised the concern from detrimental treatment by their co-workers, contractors, partner agencies, agency workers, apprentices/trainees and volunteers.
If you are unsure whether your concern falls under this policy, raise it anyway. We will help determine the most appropriate route. If you do not wish to raise it formally in writing, you can contact the Head of HR confidentially, who can provide you with advice and guidance.
What is the difference between making a complaint and blowing the whistle?
Whistleblowing is about raising concerns that are in the public interest. It usually relates to wrongdoing, risk, danger, malpractice, or illegal activity that could affect customers, service users, members of the public, colleagues, or the Council. The individual raising the concern is not usually directly affected and has no personal interest in the outcome. Their role is to report their concerns by providing clear and factual information, rather than proving the wrongdoing.
A complaint or grievance is different because it relates to an individual's own circumstances. It is raised when someone believes they have been personally affected by unfair treatment, a breach of their employment rights, discrimination, harassment, or other unacceptable behaviour. In these cases, the individual is seeking a personal remedy or resolution.
Employees with concerns about their employment, such as pay, terms and conditions, or other workplace issues, should use the Council's Grievance Procedure. Concerns relating to unacceptable behaviour, harassment, bullying, or discrimination should be raised under the Acceptable Behaviour Policy. It also covers contractors, agency staff and anyone else engaged to work at the Council. Agency workers will be covered by this policy and are expected to adhere to it, however, reference should also be made to their own policies and procedures - please see Agency Induction Handbook.
Both policies are available on MyView, for individuals with no access please email: hrpolicy@torbay.gov.uk
Some examples showing the differences are as follows:
Grievance:
- An employee's complaint about the type of work that they are being asked to do. For example, acts or omissions of non-compliance.
- An employee's complaint that they have received insufficient safety training.
- An employee's complaint about the hours that they are expected to work
- An employee’s complaint that they have been subjected to unwanted sexual comments or behaviour by a colleague or manager.
Protected disclosure:
- A disclosure that an individual has been instructed to carry out actions that they genuinely believe to be illegal, e.g. to falsify tax returns.
- A disclosure that safety rules within the workplace are routinely being flouted, thus endangering safety of employees and/or the public.
- A disclosure that the requirements imposed by the organisation on a group of employees, represent a breach of the working time legislation.
- A disclosure that managers are routinely ignoring or dismissing reports of sexual harassment, or not adequately mitigating risk of sexual harassment creating a culture where such behaviour is tolerated and employees are placed at risk.
Safeguarding Whistleblowers
In accordance with the law, the Council undertakes that no individual who reports a concern in the public interest under this procedure will be subjected to any detriment as a result. In the event that the individual believes they are being subjected to a detriment by any co-worker, contractor, partner agency, agency worker, apprentice/trainee or volunteer they have the right to raise any concerns of harassment via the Council’s Acceptable Behaviour Policy.
Confidentiality
The Council will make every effort to protect your identity when you raise a concern and do not want your name disclosed. Complete confidentiality cannot always be guaranteed: the investigation itself may reveal the source of the information, and disclosure may be necessary to investigate the matter, meet a legal obligation or address an immediate risk. Where possible, any necessary disclosure will be discussed with you beforehand. Depending on the outcome, you may also be required to provide a formal witness statement as evidence in court.
Anonymous allegations
We encourage individuals to use their name because this helps us clarify information, protect them from detriment and provide feedback. However anonymous concerns will still be considered when taking into account the following factors:
- The seriousness of the issue(s) raised;
- The credibility of the concern; and
- The likelihood of confirming the allegation from attributable sources.
Untrue allegations
Where an allegation is made but not confirmed by the investigation, no action will be taken against the person who raised the concern. If, however, there is reasonable evidence that an allegation has been made by an employee, maliciously, or with the primary intent of personal gain, action will be taken in line with the Council’s Disciplinary procedure which can be found on MyView.
Procedure
The purpose of this procedure is to enable individuals to raise concerns directly with the Council so that they can be properly considered and, where appropriate, investigated and addressed. Individuals also have the right to raise concerns outside of the Council. Further information on doing so is provided in the section Raising a Concern Outside of the Council.
Please see Appendix 1 for ‘how to raise a concern’ process diagram.
1. How to speak up and raise a concern
Concerns should normally be raised in writing using either of the options below:
- Use the online reporting form.
- Download the Whistleblowing Reporting Form, available on MyView under My Documents > Section 2 Conduct and Performance Management > 2.20a Whistleblowing Reporting Form. Completed forms should be emailed to whistle.blowing@torbay.gov.uk.
Written concerns may be addressed to the Council's Director of Finance (Monitoring Officer), the Council's most senior officer, or the Devon Audit Partnership (Internal Audit). Employees who are members of a recognised trade union may also wish to seek advice from their trade union representative.
The concern should include clear details of the matter being reported. Where it is not possible to raise a concern in writing, reports can be made by telephone via the Devon Audit Partnership whistleblowing line 01392 383438 or 01803 207407.
2. How the complaint will be dealt with
The Chairperson of the Finance, Ethics and Probity Committee will notify the Finance, Ethics and Probity Group of the matter in order for initial investigations to take place and recommendations for action. The Finance, Ethics and Probity Group is made-up of members from the Council’s Finance, Human Resources, Audit and Legal Services departments, including the Council’s Monitoring Officer. (For clarity, “The Group” refers to the Finance, Ethics and Probity Group).
The Chairperson of the Finance, Ethics and Probity Committee will take overall responsibility for action in regard to the concern raised, including the Council’s formal written response to the matter.
Within ten working days of a concern being received, the Chairperson of the Finance, Ethics and Probity Committee will write to the individual raising the concern: Acknowledging that the concern has been received;
- Indicating how the matter will be dealt with;
- Informing the individual whether any initial enquiries have been made;
- Informing the individual whether further investigations will take place and if not, the reason for this;
- Give some indication of timescales.
Following the Group’s initial investigation should the Group consider that the concern raised falls outside of the scope of this policy, the individual raising the concern will be advised of alternative courses of action to take, for example, to raise the concern under one of the Council’s other policies. If after initial investigation it becomes clear that the matter uncovers criminal activity or welfare/safeguarding concerns, these will be reported directly to the Police and/or other relevant external organisations for further action. The individual will be advised of this course of action, and the Council shall take no further action in respect of the concern raised unless requested by the Police or external organisation that the concern has been referred to.
3. How the council will respond
Following its initial investigation, the action recommended by the Group will be dependent on the nature of the concern raised and may:
- Be resolved by agreed action without the need for further investigation
- Be investigated by management or by Audit or Human Resources (as appropriate)
- Be referred to the Police
- Form the subject of an independent inquiry
- Be referred to the external auditor
Should an investigation be necessary, the Group will appoint an appropriate investigation team from within the Council. The investigation will be dealt with as expediently as possible, with an estimated timescale for completion to be provided to the individual raising the concern at the start, by the Group.
Wherever possible, we will keep the individual who raised the concern updated on progress and provide feedback on outcomes, subject to legal and confidentiality considerations.
4. Reporting suspected fraud and suspected money laundering
Torbay Council is committed to protecting the public purse from fraud and impropriety. All employees have an obligation to prevent fraud.
All employees are expected to report any instances of suspected fraud or money laundering immediately. This includes any activities that appear to be dishonest, illegal or unethical.
Employees must comply with all applicable money laundering regulations, policies and processes designed to prevent money laundering. This includes understanding and adhering to the procedures for identifying and reporting suspicious activity as outlined in the money laundering process on the intranet.
Reports of suspected fraud or money laundering should be made to the Corporate Fraud Team using the reporting fraud form available at Torbay.gov.uk. All reports are treated as confidential.
Employees must not:
- Disclose a report of fraud or money laundering to anyone especially the suspected person.
- Investigate fraud or money laundering themselves as they could find themselves guilty of an offence and will be in breach of policy.
Where an employee is called to an investigation meeting, they may be accompanied by a Trade Union representative or work colleague and such representative or colleague will be required to formally agree to any matters arising at that meeting being kept confidential.
Following the outcome of the investigation process, the Group will inform the Finance Director/most Senior Officer of the outcome, and an appropriate course of action will be agreed.
The Finance Director/most Senior Officer will put the formal response in writing to the individual at the earliest opportunity.
The individual raising the concern is not entitled to be able to determine the outcome of the investigation process or to insist that disciplinary action must be taken, or a prosecution instigated.
There is no further recourse under this policy, however, should the individual wish to pursue the matter further, they have the right to report their concerns to an external organisation.
Advice and support
Due regard and sensitivity will be exercised by all involved in the process to ensure that the individual raising the concern does not suffer detrimental treatment as a result of raising a complaint.
The Council offers to all its staff access to a range of health and wellbeing support including:
- Free confidential Counselling service
- Wellbeing Team - further information about support and services available to you can be found on the intranet - Wellbeing at Work or email wellbeing@torbay.gov.uk.
- HR team – email hroperations@torbay.gov.uk for advice or guidance
- Trade Union representative
Below is a range of external support you can contact before or after raising a concern: - Speak Up Direct provides free, independent, confidential advice on the speaking up process.
- The charity Protect provides confidential and legal advice on speaking up.
- The Trades Union Congress provides information on how to join a trade union.
- The Law Society may be able to point you to other sources of advice and support.
- The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) gives advice and assistance, including on early conciliation regarding employment disputes. Telephone: 0300 123 1100
- National Audit Office
- Public Disclosures Whistleblowing Hotline Tel: 020 7798 7999
- Devon and Cornwall Police Tel:101 www.devon-cornwall.police.uk
- Whistleblowing for employees: Gov.uk/whistleblowingMonitoring of the Policy
Monitoring of the policy
The policy will be monitored on an annual basis by the Finance, Ethics and Probity Group, who have overall responsibility for the maintenance and operation of this policy. The Group will maintain a record of concerns raised and the outcomes (in a form which does not endanger confidentiality) and will report as necessary to the Chair of the Audit Committee.
The Council will use themes and learning from concerns raised to improve services, governance, risk management and employee experience.
Equality statement
We are committed to ensuring that no individual is treated less favourably or disadvantaged on the basis of any protected characteristic, as defined in equality legislation. Care will be taken to ensure that groups who have historically experienced exclusion or inequality are not adversely impacted in the application of this policy. Monitoring will be undertaken to ensure fairness, consistency, and compliance with our equality obligations.
Raising a concern outside of the Council
If an individual wishes to take the matter outside the Council, they need to ensure that they do not disclose confidential information or that disclosure would be privileged. This can be checked with the Local Government Ombudsman who will also advise on ways to proceed.
To register a new concern with the Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman, the individual raising the concern is encouraged to read the Ombudsman’s step by step process for making a complaint which can be found on their website.
The individual may wish to seek their own independent legal advice before or throughout the process. The Government has produced a document Blowing the Whistle to a Prescribed Person – List of Prescribed people and Bodies. It lists the appropriate organisations to handle whistleblowing concerns and should be referred to for up-to-date advice and guidance about who to contact.
Other contacts
- Public Sector Audit Appointments Ltd (External Audit) for England and Wales
- Public Disclosures Hotline Tel: 0845 0522 646
- Devon and Cornwall Police - Telephone: 101
- Protect - Telephone: 020 3117 2520
- ACAS - Telephone: 0300 123 1100
Whistleblowing reporting form
Use this form to report a concern under Torbay Council’s Whistleblowing policy and procedure.