Budget Monitoring Quarter 2
To consider the Budget Monitoring Report for Quarter 2 (to include Revenue Budget and Capital Budget monitoring together with financial and delivery details of the Capital Programme) and make recommendations to the Cabinet.
Minutes:
The Cabinet Member for Housing and Finance, Councillor Tyerman, introduced the submitted report outlining the forecast revenue and capital position for 2026/27, which was currently an overspend of £1.94 million. Members were advised that significant work was continuing between Cabinet and the Senior Leadership Team to mitigate Service overspends, while higher interest rates had generated additional treasury management income, although not at a level sufficient to offset all budget pressures.
The Board undertook detailed scrutiny of the report and discussed the ongoing challenges associated with balancing the budget, including the potential future use of reserves. Members discussed pressures within the housing market arising from legislative and economic changes and their impact on homelessness and temporary accommodation.
Members asked the following questions:
· What reserve implications would arise if the budget could not be brought back into balance?
· Why had home to school transport costs increased significantly and what further mitigation measures were available?
· Why were there underspends in some Children's Services budgets and what impact would this have on service delivery?
· Why had the expected Safety Valve funding for the Dedicated Schools Grant support fallen short of expectations?
· Could future reports provide more detailed information on investment fund performance?
· Was SWISCo accelerating its programme of replacing diesel vehicles?
· Was the Dedicated Schools Grant overspend £5.8 million?
· Were children attending schools outside Torbay contributing to home to school transport pressures?
· What were the implications of the Wincanton tenancy arrangements?
· Could more information be provided on the financial sustainability plan in respect of Artificial Intelligence?
· What impact had the reprioritisation of regeneration funding from Station Square to Crossways had?
· Why had climate capital budget provision been removed and what was the position of the Nightingale Park solar farm project?
· What was the latest position regarding the Coroner's Service and associated costs?
The following responses were received:
· Reserves may need to be used to balance the 2026/27 Revenue Budget, but the Council was seeking to minimise this because of future pressures, particularly in Adult Social Care.
· Increased home to school transport costs were mainly driven by higher complexity of need rather than increased pupil numbers. Eligibility processes had been strengthened and alternative transport solutions were being explored.
· Some transport costs related to tribunal-directed placements outside the area, although reviews were taking place to identify alternative arrangements.
· Children's placement costs were being driven by growing demand and complexity. Work continued to increase kinship arrangements, special guardianship orders and local provision.
· Spending pressures in Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) and support services partly reflected commissioning issues and contract changes, rather than a reduction in services.
· The Council had received less benefit than expected through Safety Valve arrangements and was exploring options to challenge this position.
· Investment property performance was monitored monthly and future reporting could provide additional detail.
· Electric fleet technology had previously presented limitations, but further assessment was underway using learning from other operators. A written response was requested on opportunities to accelerate SWISCo fleet replacement and the transition away from diesel vehicles.
· The Dedicated Schools Grant deficit stood at £5.8 million.
· The Wincanton tenancy ended when the tenant served notice during rent negotiations, although Officers were optimistic that a higher future rental income could be secured.
· Station Square remained a live option, but Crossways was currently being prioritised.
· Climate capital expenditure depended partly on external partner decisions, including NHS timescales for progressing the Nightingale Solar Farm. A written response would be provided regarding climate capital investment funding changes and project phasing.
· Devon County Council was now leading the Coroner's Service, and discussions continued on costs, service levels and improvement planning.
Members requested the following:
1. Details of the Collection Fund collection rate data and to consider this being included in future reports.
2. A more detailed breakdown of investment fund income and expenditure to be included in a future report.
3. A report to be brought to a future meeting on the financial sustainability plan for Artificial Intelligence.
Resolved (unanimously):
That the Overview and Scrutiny Board note the forecast revenue outturn position and the amendments made to the published 2026/27 Capital Investment Plan.
Supporting documents:
-
Q2 Report 2026-27, item 39.
PDF 546 KB -
Appendix 1, item 39.
PDF 244 KB - Restricted enclosure View the reasons why document 39./3 is restricted
Contact Governance Support
- Email: governance.support@torbay.gov.uk
- Tel: 01803 207087
- Fax: 01803 207112
- Torbay Council
Town Hall
Castle Circus
Torquay
TQ1 3DR
- Brixham Town Council
- Budget digest
- Calendar
- Civic Mayor
- Committees
- Constitution
- Councillors' allowances
- Councillors' behaviour, interests and standards
- Decisions
- Decision lists
- Forward plans
- Get involved and have your say
- How the Council works
- Independent remuneration panel
- Meetings
- Outside bodies
- Overview & Scrutiny
- Search documents
- Subscribe to updates
- What's new
- Your Councillors
- Your MPs
- Become a Councillor